A recent post at Confessions of a Former Conservative begins with a quote from facebook on grade sharing:
Support Grade Sharing !
This new rule will only affect students with over a 3.8 GPA.
what it will do, is take a percentage of their grade and it will be applied to the students with a lower grade .Share this with your kids, students, and liberal friends and watch the sparks fly !!!
This apparently comes from an argument on taxation, though I don’t have a facebook account so I haven’t tried to track down the details.
I agree with formerconservative, that it is a poor analogy. Beyond that, my take on the taxation issue is a little different.
For myself, I have done reasonably well economically. In fact, I have done well enough that I can afford to have a blog. Well, okay, it’s a free wordpress blog, so that doesn’t say much, though it does require computer and internet access. My ability to do well economically has depended on my use of social support services. These include education, transportation, communication, etc. So it is only fair that I pay part of the cost of those important support services. Those at the highest income levels depend disproportionately more on those social support services. They might not depend on them for individual needs – perhaps they use private schools, and live in a private estate with its own private roads. However, their ability to earn their income does depend on those services being available.
I disagreed with the Reagan tax cuts and with the Bush tax cuts, because they were paid for by increasing debt that our children and grand children will be responsible for. The argument from some on the political right – “It’s my money, and the government should not take it away from me” – is just nonsense. It should be understood as a declaration that they are deadbeats, wanting to sponge off society but unwilling to pay for the services that made their income possible.
Getting back to the grade question – yes, in some ways, that also depends on social services, such as education systems and public libraries. However, those who earn high grades are already paying it back. There is nothing more rewarding for a teachers, than to see their students do well. And having a well educated work force is good for the economy.